IV

It is a good piece to one degree. The Black, white and reddish orange are nice colors. The angular borders contrast well with the center which is messy and asymmetrical. The use of colors I would say (8.4/10). Shape and form is great (8.9/10) but the biggest complaint I have is the texture. The inside has a great brush looking texture but the background looks very pure and clean. Great but many spots in the black and orange look like pure along with brush strokes. Inconsistent texture takes away from the consistent simplicity of the work. (7.7/10) Consistency is consistently cool.  Overall I would say that (8.3/10) piece is great. Good luck on your future works.